Women in Love

Source: Wikipedia (CC BY-SA).

Women in Love was written during the First World War (largely 1916-1917) and published in 1920, after Lawrence struggled to find a publisher willing to risk its frank sexual content following the 1915 suppression of his previous novel, The Rainbow. It is a direct sequel, continuing the story of the Brangwen sisters, Ursula and Gudrun. The war years profoundly shaped the novel's dark, apocalyptic tone, though the conflict is never named directly; Lawrence and his German-born wife Frieda faced suspicion and hostility in wartime England, deepening his sense of a civilization in crisis. Lawrence's evolving interests in psychoanalysis and Nietzschean philosophy, together with his complicated relationships with contemporaries such as the critic and editor John Middleton Murry and the painter Mark Gertler, fed into the novel's characters: Gerald Crich draws partly on Murry, the sculptor Loerke partly on Gertler (whose painting Merry-Go-Round provoked an intense response from Lawrence), while Rupert Birkin is widely regarded as Lawrence's own self-portrait. To avoid censorship, Lawrence first arranged a private limited edition in America in 1920, with a British trade edition following in 1921. The novel is widely regarded as Lawrence's masterpiece and the fullest fictional expression of his philosophy of blood-consciousness, individual selfhood, and the destructive advance of industrial modernity over organic life.

The novel follows sisters Ursula and Gudrun Brangwen in the Midlands colliery town of Beldover. Ursula, a schoolteacher, enters a turbulent, philosophically charged relationship with Rupert Birkin, a school inspector whose ideas about love, selfhood, and the sickness of modern civilization closely echo Lawrence's own. Gudrun, a sculptor, becomes entangled with Gerald Crich, heir to the local colliery, who modernizes his father's mines with ruthless industrial efficiency. Running alongside the two courtships is an intense, unresolved bond between Birkin and Gerald, dramatized in a celebrated nude wrestling scene that hints at a desire for male intimacy beyond conventional friendship. Birkin urges Gerald toward this deeper bond, but Gerald cannot embrace it. The two couples' relationships develop in counterpoint: Birkin and Ursula move, after considerable conflict, toward a difficult but affirming union, while Gudrun and Gerald's relationship grows destructive, marked by cruelty and a battle of wills. Earlier in the novel, Gerald's sister Diana and her fiance drown during a water party, and Gerald's authoritarian father dies not long after; later, the action shifts to the Alps, where the two couples travel together for a snowbound holiday. There, Gudrun becomes drawn to the decadent sculptor Loerke, provoking Gerald's jealousy and psychological collapse. Gerald attacks Gudrun and then wanders into the snow, where he freezes to death. The novel closes with Birkin grieving Gerald and confessing to Ursula that he had wanted, alongside his love for her, a further form of eternal union with a man - a desire she cannot accept, leaving the novel's central questions about love and selfhood unresolved.

• Love and power struggles between the sexes
• Industrialism versus organic/natural life
• The crisis of modern civilization
• Individual selfhood versus fusion with another
• Male friendship and homoerotic desire
• Death and destruction as products of the machine age
• The limits of will and ego in human relationships

• ◆Symbolic set-piece scenes - episodes like the wrestling match and the Alpine finale carry the novel's philosophical weight
• ◆Leitmotif and repetition - recurring images (stars, ice, flowers) accrue meaning across chapters
• ◆Free indirect discourse - shifting close narration exposes characters' inner psychological states
• ◆Extended philosophical dialogue - characters debate ideas at length, carrying much of the novel's argument
• ◆Elemental and animal imagery - characters are repeatedly likened to natural forces and creatures
• ◆Structural counterpoint - the parallel, contrasting courtships of the two sisters organize the novel

• ◆Water and drowning - recurrent images of drowning suggest engulfment and loss of selfhood in love
• ◆Ice and snow - the Alpine setting embodies sterility, death, and the reductive extremity of the will
• ◆The colliery and machinery - Gerald's mines symbolize industrial modernity's domination over organic life
• ◆The moon's reflection on the water (the 'Moony' chapter) - Birkin's stoning of the moon's reflection figures his struggle against destructive fusion with the female
• ◆Loerke's statuette - decadent, dehumanized art symbolizing the corruption Gudrun is drawn toward

Women in Love helped establish the modern psychological novel of ideas, influencing later writers who explored sexuality, gender, and the inner life with similar candor; critics have noted, for instance, that Doris Lessing's The Golden Notebook opens with a reworking of Women in Love's opening scene and echoes its portrait of two women friends navigating love and independence. Its frank treatment of homoeroticism and its refusal of censorship made it a landmark in the long struggle over literary obscenity in Britain and America, anticipating later legal and cultural battles such as those over Lady Chatterley's Lover. The novel's symbolic, rhythmic prose and its rejection of conventional plot in favor of psychological and philosophical patterning influenced subsequent modernist and post-war fiction concerned with the inner life and the critique of industrial modernity.

• ◆Women in Love (1969 film), directed by Ken Russell, starring Alan Bates, Oliver Reed, Glenda Jackson, and Jennie Linden; Glenda Jackson won the Academy Award for Best Actress

• The Rainbow by D. H. Lawrence
• Lady Chatterley's Lover by D. H. Lawrence
• Sons and Lovers by D. H. Lawrence
• To the Lighthouse by Virginia Woolf
• Ulysses by James Joyce

1. 1Women in Love is a direct sequel to The Rainbow (1915), which had been prosecuted for obscenity and withdrawn from sale, so Lawrence initially struggled to find a British publisher for its successor.
2. 2Lawrence first published Women in Love as a private subscription edition in New York in 1920 to sidestep censorship before it appeared in Britain in 1921.
3. 3The character Rupert Birkin is widely regarded as Lawrence's most direct fictional self-portrait.
4. 4The novel's famous nude wrestling scene between Birkin and Gerald was considered highly controversial for its homoerotic implications.
5. 5The 1969 Ken Russell film adaptation brought the novel's wrestling scene to wide public attention and won Glenda Jackson an Academy Award.